Making an informed choice in an election has never been an easy job. Bias, half-truths, and even outright lies have likely obscured voters’ understanding since the first election in history. Yet, in our age of information, the volume of news stories, social media posts, and campaign ads we must wade through to find the truth has become a daunting task for even the most determined voter. Instead of wondering about real, pressing questions and issues that affect our lives, we are instead waylaid by the more nefarious question, “How do I even know what the truth is?”
Several years ago, Lower School Dean of STEM Cathy Hamblet and I viewed a documentary about math education called “Counted Out.” It spoke to the importance of a good math education in building informed citizens who can question the facts, figures, and statistics offered to them as truth. They spoke of “looking under the hood” when we see percentages presented as facts and probing to find out more. This stance, probing for the truth, is at the heart of a great education across all subject areas. In literacy, we teach students about the ways in which authors persuade and infuse or reveal bias in their writing. Students have been taught to follow links to verify sources, confirm facts in more than one place, and to read a variety of articles on the same topic. In science, we replicate results and isolate variables to understand the truth of what we perceive. In historical study, we interrogate first-person accounts of events, considering multiple perspectives, hoping to get at what really happened at that moment in time.
Throughout the Bush Lower School, I watch our teachers build civically engaged students in search of the truth. A key truth our youngest students grapple with is that there is not just one right way to be a person or a family. Our Kindergarten and First Grade classrooms learn how to acknowledge and positively discuss differences between themselves and their families. Our teachers expertly help students navigate the moments they notice that they don’t look the same, think the same, or have the same tastes as others. Noticing differences is natural, but at Bush, respecting and even celebrating differences is core to our social-emotional curriculum. Each Kindergarten student gets to be the Big Cheese once during the year and shares about what makes them unique. Each First Grade family is the Star Family for one week and teaches the grade about traditions and customs their family observes. In both cases, students are invited to make connections and also wonder respectfully about differences. Students learn we don’t all live and think the same way and why that’s a good thing! This support and celebration helps build our students’ tolerance for discourse about complex issues with many perspectives. We hope this foundation builds independently thinking global citizens of the future who are able to vote for what is not just best for them, but best for their whole diverse community.
In Second and Third grade, students launch their school year uncovering the truth of data presented visually, such as in graphs or charts. Students learn to read several types of graphs and how to interpret them. They also learn to gather data of their own and create graphs to represent their findings. This exposure to visual depictions of numbers and quantitative data, as well as the experience of gathering that data, gives students two important learning opportunities. First, they begin to understand how to make sense of data and to build their capacity to question it. Third Grade students, for example, learn how influential the scale of a graph can be, making small differences look quite large. Second, these experiences give students exposure to the power of polling members of their community. Canvassing for voters’ opinions is key for candidates to tailor their message, predict election outcomes, and understand what issues matter most across states and regions. Valid, reliable, and clearly depicted data is essential to understand the needs of a community.
As students transition from learning to read to reading to learn, they begin to consider the intent and purpose of an author. Fourth and Fifth Grade students spend a significant portion of their year reading informational texts. Early on, students understand that authors make choices when they write, and what is and isn’t included in a text are the result of these choices. At times, an author’s opinion or bias may influence what information ends up on the page. Because of this, students are taught to confirm information in multiple sources and read the ‘About’ tabs on webpages to verify trustworthiness. In social studies, both Fourth and Fifth Grade students learn about the differences between primary and secondary sources. They come to understand that a first-hand account of an event can be both true and incomplete; it can exclude the facts of others' lived experience. This understanding builds healthy skepticism and critical thinking in our readers that will be necessary to make truly informed choices at the ballot box later in life.
Educating these young, future voters is work that we hold sacred, and that fills us with immense hope. With each lesson taught to equip our students to uncover truth, we see the first sparks of advocates, change makers, and even candidates. So what is the truth? The truth is that, while the truth will always be elusive, each step we take toward understanding it brings us closer to ourselves and strengthens our community.